As a college admissions consultant based in Crown Point, Indiana, I work with families across the country — and around the world. But lately, I’ve noticed a growing unease among parents right here at home.
The question isn’t just “Can my child get into Purdue or IU?” It’s “Why is it getting so hard?”
Part of the answer lies thousands of miles away. In 2025, the United States has made it more difficult for international students to study here. Visa approvals are slower. Government scholarships, like the prestigious Fulbright Program, are shrinking. Earlier this year, dozens of international Fulbright awards were revoked with no clear explanation, prompting the resignation of the entire Foreign Scholarship Board. These weren’t administrative errors — they were signals. To the world, they read as: You’re no longer welcome here.
And yet, demand has not declined. The Ivy League remains the pinnacle of aspiration for students from around the globe. But more than ever, international students are setting their sights on public universities — especially top-tier flagships like Purdue, Indiana University, and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. These institutions offer world-class research, respected brand names, and — crucially — more seats.
This is where the issue becomes very local.
Many families in Northwest Indiana are starting to feel boxed out. Their sons and daughters have worked hard, maintained strong GPAs, and taken AP or dual-credit courses. But even with solid credentials, admission feels more uncertain.
The culprit, they say, is an increasingly competitive — and global — pool of applicants.
And they’re not wrong. Public universities were founded to serve in-state students. But over the past two decades, many of these schools have faced
serious budget cuts. To stay afloat — and competitive — they’ve turned to full-pay students. That often means international students and out-of-state applicants who bring in significantly more tuition than Hoosier residents.
It’s become a flashpoint in the broader debate about fairness, access, and the mission of public education. For local taxpayers, it raises uncomfortable
questions: Why is my kid struggling to get into a school we help fund? Why does it feel like universities are recruiting abroad while ignoring students here at home?
These are fair questions — and they deserve honest answers.
From the university’s perspective, admitting international students is often a financial necessity. It’s not about turning away locals — it’s about survival in a system where state funding has steadily declined. International applicants often pay full freight, don’t require financial aid, and boost a university’s global reputation. In that light, it’s easy to see why admissions offices view them as essential.
But optics matter. And so does public trust. When families in Crown Point, Valparaiso, or Merrillville feel that their children are being squeezed out by students from Beijing or Bangalore, it erodes confidence in the system.
Meanwhile, the international students are adapting too. As the front door to elite schools narrows, many are entering through the side: enrolling first at second- or third-tier U.S. colleges, with plans to transfer after a year or two. They know the rules. Once they’re on American soil, with good grades and recommendations, the odds of getting into a top school improve dramatically.
But in 2025, it’s a complex game of positioning, paperwork, and planning.
Positioning means understanding how to present yourself in a way that aligns with what top colleges are seeking. For example, a student interested in
economics might build a unique profile by launching a financial literacy podcast for teens, demonstrating initiative, leadership, and a passion for their field — qualities that resonate with admissions committees beyond just grades and test scores.
Allysia Findley, a member of the Editorial Board of The Wall Street Journal, shared her thoughts with me on how writing for a high school newspaper can help shape one’s career: “I do think writing for a student newspaper can foster intellectual curiosity, originality, and an appreciation for the First Amendment. Original reporting and angles are more important than ever in the AI age. A student’s reporting for a school newspaper may also provide a better reflection of his writing skills than an essay, which can be generated by a chatbot.”
Paperwork refers to the increasingly burdensome and technical side of the process: financial aid forms like the CSS Profile and FAFSA, and supplemental essays tailored for each school.
Planning is the long-term strategy: selecting the right courses and extracurriculars early in high school, deciding when to take the SAT or ACT, and understanding when to apply early decision versus regular. A well-advised student might decide to apply Early Decision to the University of Pennsylvania, knowing their odds are statistically stronger in that round — but only after confirming that Penn is a genuine first choice and that the family can commit financially.
As someone who advises both U.S. and international students, I tell them the same thing: stop obsessing over rankings.
The U.S. News & World Report list may dominate headlines, but it doesn’t tell the whole story. Some of the best programs in engineering, AI, business, and agriculture are found at public institutions that rarely make the top 10.
In fact, some of the most cutting-edge research in America is happening not at Ivy League campuses, but at places like Purdue, Michigan State, and Texas A&M. For Northwest Indiana families, that should be reassuring. Your child doesn’t need to get into Harvard to thrive. But they do need a smart strategy.
So who gets in?
This question often catches local families off guard. The students who prepare early, understand the real admissions landscape and adapt their approach. They treat college admissions not as a lottery but as a carefully planned process that can be learned and strategically navigated. That includes understanding how the competition prepares, and applying to a broad mix of academically appropriate schools — even if they aren’t household names.
Most of all, it means staying informed. Whether you’re a family in Crown Point or Bangalore, the college landscape is shifting. The American dream is still within reach.
Gerald Bradshaw is an international college admissions consultant with Bradshaw College Consulting in Crown Point.