The Atlanta Braves are going nowhere this season, as has been made crystal clear by recent injuries and the team’s performance since exactly March 27th. And as with any 45-62 team sitting behind the likes of the Miami Marlins in the division standings, the plan for the Braves trade deadline seemed to be just as obvious: sell and recoup prospect talent. But with the deadline on Thursday coming and going, General Manager Alex Anthopoulos instead decided to sit on his hands, keeping with his recent trend of perplexing decisions.
A Baffling Braves Deadline Strategy
To his credit, Anthopolous did make one trade on MLB deadline day, flipping reliever Rafael Montero to the Tigers for minor league infielder prospect Jim Jarvis. Montero has a 5.50 ERA with Atlanta this year, and Jarvis is a former 11th-round pick currently hitting .242 in Double-A. Outside of that, the only other moves in recent weeks were desperate trades for depth starters to cover the innings voided by the staggering number of currently injured hurlers. That is nothing short of malpractice for a team with the 26th-ranked farm system by MLB.com coming into the season.
Ironically, the most talked about trade piece is the one that makes the most sense staying put: Marcell Ozuna. As the days and hours ticked down, it became increasingly clear that Ozuna’s trade market was far from robust, with his 10-and-5 rights, DH-only status, lingering hip injury, and even past legal issues playing a role.
The Braves have a little more than three more hours to find suitors for Ozuna and Iglesias. Ozuna’s past legal issues and 10-5 might affect his market. But the greater obstacle is that as a true DH he has limited fits.
— Mark Bowman (@mlbbowman) July 31, 2025
It’s hard to fathom holding onto a guy facing free agency with very little chance of re-signing by all accounts. That said, it seems likely the demand for Ozuna’s services was next to nothing. With catchers Drake Baldwin and Sean Murphy largely usurping Ozuna from the DH spot in recent weeks, he probably won’t see regular playing time during his swan song with the Braves either, making it an overall depressing exit from Atlanta for a fan favorite.
Relievers?
Anthopoulos may be able to explain away Ozuna, but he’ll have a hard time defending his failure to move any of the multiple veteran relievers on expiring deals. The big name is pending free agent closer Raisel Iglesias, who should absolutely be on a plane right now but will stay put instead. Pierce Johnson, who has a club option for 2026, was also a candidate to be traded and likely to net a decent return, but he remains in Atlanta as well. Aaron Bummer is under contract for 2026, but would have surely returned a quality prospect of two, given other deadline deals. The bullpen was Anthopoulos’ only area to look for quality trade chips, and for his only move at the Braves trade deadline to be sending off one of the worst arms in Montero for an obscure prospect is highly questionable talent management.
A Tough Look
Anthopoulos has already backed up his uneventful Thursday, stating that he wouldn’t dump players purely for payroll purposes without receiving assets for the future. That’s reasonable, but it’s hard to fathom that he couldn’t find a deal he could at least live with for any of the mentioned players. The Braves badly need a talent injection into their barren farm system, and this just stinks of a missed opportunity.
Anthopoulos said the #Braves weren’t going to trade away any players just for payroll purposes — i.e., they weren’t going to dump guys to save money and get nothing of value back in terms of talent.
— David O’Brien (@DOBrienATL) July 31, 2025
A dud of a trade deadline is hardly surprising in the Braves’ season from hell. It seems Anthopoulos hasn’t pushed one right button since the Chris Sale trade, and this will go down as yet another stain on his once-proud resume. This offseason will be all the more crucial because of it, with the organization in dire need of a shakeup and Anthopoulos’ equity from 2021 quickly running out.
The post The Braves Trade Deadline Was a Failure by Alex Anthopoulous appeared first on Last Word On Baseball.